On this episode of the Rules of the Game podcast (the third in an eight-part, issue-specific podcast series), we’ll discuss recent headlines impacting criminal legal reform advocates and explain how nonprofits can take action with legislative, executive branch, and judicial branch advocacy. From responding to legislative proposals to initiating litigation, nonprofits nationwide are standing up to fight for our rights and critical reforms to our criminal legal system. This episode will highlight their work and provide information about the rules that apply when nonprofits engage in advocacy to ensure due process, protect the rights of the accused, and improve judicial systems.
Attorneys for this episode
Monika Graham
Melissa Marichal Zayas
Natalie Roetzel Ossenfort
Show notes
· Recent Headlines: Legislation, Litigation, and More!
o Legislation:
§ Family Notification of Death, Injury, or Illness in Custody Act: Bipartisan legislation introduced in the U.S. Senate. Would require the DOJ to issue guidance on how federal prisons should promptly notify families of incarcerated individuals who become seriously ill or pass away in prison.
o Litigation
§ Criminal legal reform advocates scored a win in Michigan recently, when the MI Supreme Court ruled that mandatory / automatic life without parole sentences for 19-20 year olds convicted of murder are unconstitutional.
o Executive Branch Actions:
§ Earlier this year, the DOJ froze work on police reform and other civil rights cases. Now, (in the absence of DOJ leadership on these issues), the burden has shifted to local governments to take action.
o Keep on Your Radar: Trump’s “Opening Salvo” in His War Against Criminal Justice Reform Starts With This Nonprofit
§ The Vera Institute of Justice, a major criminal justice reform nonprofit, had all five of its federal grants—worth about $5 million—abruptly terminated by the Department of Justice under Attorney General Pam Bondi, a key Trump ally.
§ Evaluate your funding sources, and make sure you’re not overly dependent on any one source.
· Non-Lobbying Advocacy
o Nonpartisan Advocacy 101: 501(c)(3)s cannot support or oppose candidates for public office, but they can…
o Educate the public about issues of importance to your organization.
§ Equal Justice Initiative recently provided education related to the wrongful incarceration and conviction of black defendants in murder cases. Not only did they report on research from the National Registry of Exonerations that black Americans are nearly 8x more likely to be wrongfully convicted of murder, but they noted that they are also likely to spend more years in prison than wrongfully convicted white people.
o Hold a rally:
§ Earlier this year, a coalition of criminal justice reform advocates and nonprofits in New Mexico held a rally to call attention to the reality of mass incarceration and to propose common-sense alternatives to harsh prison sentences.
o Initiate or participate in litigation:
§ The Innocence Project (AFJ Member) and other members of the Innocence Network, engage in litigation on behalf of wrongfully convicted persons who can be proven innocent with DNA and other types of evidence.
o Fund Advocacy
§ Private and public foundations can support organizations advancing their charitable missions through general operating grants and/or specific project grants, ensuring flexibility and sustainability in pursuit of shared goals.
· Lobbying
o 501(c)(3) public charities are also allowed to use unrestricted funds to engage in some lobbying activities.
o Tax Code Lobbying 101: Public charities can lobby, but they are limited in how much lobbying they may engage in.
§ Insubstantial part test vs. 501(h) expenditure test.
§ Under either test, lobbying includes attempts to influence legislation at any level of government.
§ Track your local, state, and federal lobbying, and stay within your lobbying limits.
o State/local level lobbyist registration and reporting requirements may also apply when engaging in legislative and executive branch advocacy.
o Ballot measure advocacy (direct lobbying) could also implicate state / local campaign finance and election laws.
o Lobbying win!
§ In March, DC Justice Lab, an AFJ member, and several other nonprofits lobbied in support of Maryland’s Second Look Act by submitting testimony to the Senate Judicial Proceedings Committee. This legislation would permit individuals convicted of certain crimes between the ages of 18 and 25, and have served over 20 years of their sentence, to petition the court to modify or reduce their sentence based on demonstrated rehabilitation. Since the committee’s hearing, the Maryland General Assembly has passedthe Second Look Act, which now awaits Governor Moore’s signature.
Resources –
· Justice & Equity: The Advocacy Playbook for Criminal Legal Reform
· Public Charities Can Lobby (Factsheet)
· Practical Guidance: what your nonprofit needs to know about lobbying in your state
· Investing in Change: A Funder’s Guide to Supporting Advocacy